Welcome to Dupe or No Dupe, the series where I pull out colors from my collection that look the same in the bottle and we find out if they’re the same….or just similar? Up today: Zoya Ryan vs. Cirque Colors Midnight Cowboy vs. Barielle Moda Bleu!
Cirque Colors Midnight Cowboy was released as part of the Metropolis Collection. Barielle Moda Bleu was released as part of the Couture Me Collection. Zoya Ryan was released as part of the Entice Collection. Photo shows 2 coats of each polish & Out The Door Top coat. Moda Blue is on the pinkie finger, Midnight Cowboy is on the ring and middle fingers and Ryan is on the index finger.
None of these are dupes to me, but they are pretty dang close. In terms of darkness, Moda Bleu and Ryan are the most similar but Moda Bleu has a slight purple tinge to it in person and Ryan is straight up navy. Midnight Cowboy falls somewhere between the two and is slightly lighter. Ryan had the best overall formula but the other two were not bad.
What do you think about this comparison? Let me know in the comments!